|
North
American Wensleydale Sheep Association
Minutes of the Meeting of the
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
via Conference Call
July 12, 2001
Directors present: Barbara
Burrows, Sherry Carlson, Myrtle Dow, Martin Dally, David Moran,
Andrea Szabo, and Sandra Hanson, Treasurer.
Directors absent: Neil Kentner
President Martin Dally called
the meeting to order 6:37 pm Pacific time.
A motion was made by Sandi Hanson to approve
the minutes of the Board meeting of 5-6-01 as written. Seconded
by Sherry Carlson, the motion was unanimously approved.
There were several items added to the agenda,
after which Barbara Burrows made a motion to accept the agenda,
Seconded by Sandi Hanson the motion was passed. Items added by Sherry
Carlson included Election of board officers, Definition of active
membership, Clarify RR issue for rams, Response to Leicester Longwool
Breeders, Promotion/Advertising.
Election of Officers
for 2001-02
Barbara Burrows was nominated for the office of President
by Sherry Carlson, seconded by Martin Dally. There were no further
nomination; Martin made a motion to close nominations, seconded
by Myrtle Dow. Barbara Burrows was unanimously elected as president.
David Moran was nominated for the office
of Vice-President by Martin Dally, seconded by Sherry Carlson. There
were no further nominations; Martin made a motion to close nominations,
seconded by Barbara Burrows. David Moran was unanimously elected
as vice president.
Sherry Carlson was nominated for the office
of Secretary by Martin Dally, seconded by Andrea Szabo. There were
no further nominations; Martin made a motion to close nominations,
seconded by David Moran. Sherry Carlson was unanimously elected
as secretary.
It was agreed that Sandra Hanson continue
in the office of Treasurer, Although Sandi is not a current Board
member, the bylaws provide that this office may be held by other
than a member of the board.
Martin Dally said that it has been a pleasure
serving as NAWSA President for its first year and felt that we have
established a good foundation for the future. Martin has no breeding
stock at this time, and felt that it will soon be appropriate for
only those members who own and breed Wensleydales to serve as directors
and guide the Association.
Number of Directors
Our bylaws state that at the discretion of the current board,
there may be from 5 to 9 directors and that the board may schedule
the election of new directors to achieve staggered terms of office.
David Moran made a motion to set the number of Directors at 7 and
to stagger the terms of office so that approximately half of the
board is elected each year. Based on our current membership of less
than 30 active members, this would still allow for almost 25% of
the membership to be on the board. The motion was seconded by Myrtle
Dow and passed unanimously.
Directors Martin Dally, Sherry Carlson, and
Andrea Szabo volunteered to serve a one-year term of office in order
to stagger the election of directors.
Manner of Elections
In our recent directors election, there were fewer nominations
than positions available and so all nominees were accepted as new
Directors. Barbara Burrows asked if we actually needed to call for
a vote from the membership and it was felt that an election was
unnecessary in this case. For future reference, Martin Dally made
a motion to state that our policy should be that if at any time
the number of nominees should be less than the number of positions
to be filled, the nominees would fill the positions without an election
being necessary. David Moran seconded the motion, unanimously approved.
Ear Tag Policy
Discussion from the recent membership meeting revealed that
members were not in favor of NAWSA issuing any type of association
identification. Sherry felt that we shouldnt make rules that
we cannot enforce, and other directors agreed that there could be
no policing the private application of such tags. David Moran made
a motion that NAWSA policy state we do not issue association ear
tags. Barbara mentioned that at the very least, all animals would
carry scrapie ID tags or tattoos and probably additional private
ID. The motion was seconded by Martin Dally and passed unanimously.
Association Newsletter
The last general membership meeting discussed the fact that
a newsletter would be a welcome addition to the Association. Kim
Caulfield has volunteered to organize it and the board discussed
the guidelines that should be followed for such a publication.
- The newsletter will be published on
line at our website location, and mailed to the few number of
members who do not have internet access.
- The president shall be responsible for review
and editing of the newsletter before distribution.
- Content of the newsletter should be concise
and consist only of factual, timely, and need-to-know information.
i.e., current industry or Wensleydale news, member activities,
AI information (Martin can supply this info), semen availability,
member & registration information (from Sherry), changes in
Federal regulations, and other such issues relevant to all of
us.
- There should be no reprinting of articles
or information from other periodicals, only a reference made to
where the info might be found.
- The membership and board did not favor having
personal opinions, editorials, or stories in our newsletter.
- If show results are available, we should report
only outstanding fleece & show results, not entire placings.
- Two times a year would be sufficient to issue
the newsletter unless there was a need for more frequent reporting.
July 1st would be a good time for one publication because it falls
after lambing and before breeding season.
Based on the above criteria, David Moran
made a motion to approve the use of a newsletter, seconded by Myrtle
Dow, the motion passed unanimously.
Member Benefits
Offered
Benefits for Active Members - Sherry Carlson presented a
proposal to make personal web pages available to all active members.
Not a true independent web site, the one-page sites would be hosted
on the associations server and be designed and maintained
by our web designer. The cost to members would be nominal, with
an annual hosting fee of $40 being paid to the association. Martin
agreed with the proposal saying that it would give a member exposure
and promotional opportunities and that we are here to serve every
member. Andrea Szabo made a motion to adopt the proposal. Seconded
by Barbara Burrows, the motion carried unanimously.
Benefits for Associate Members - The recent
membership meeting discussed the fact that Associate members are
probably our most enthusiastic supporters and as such we should
seek to retain and increase their membership. Associate members
are very interested in the availability of Wensleydale fleeces and
Sherry proposed that we issue a statement saying that the
Association encourages its active producer-members to give NAWSA
members priority status for purchasing fleeces when they become
available for sale. Board members who had waiting lists for
their fleeces commented that they would be happy to sell to NAWSA
members ahead of anyone else. The board felt that this cannot be
made a requirement, but it strongly encourages all members to adopt
this policy.
Association Fees
Myrtle Dow made a motion to adopt the fee schedule and regulations
as listed below. Andrea Szabo seconded the motion, passed unanimously.
Notable is the rule that no animal over 24 months of age will be
considered for the registry except by special consideration of the
Board. It is felt that accurate records be maintained on a timely
basis, especially during the formation of the breed.
| Active Membership |
|
Includes email and web site links
from our member roster
|
$25 per year |
| Associate Membership |
$15 per year |
| Recording & Registration
of sheep - must be a member to submit |
| Foundation ewe |
$5 |
| Animals up to 9 months of age |
$5 |
| Animals 9 -24 mos of age |
$10 |
No animal shall be accepted for recording or registration
after it is two years old unless, in the opinion of the
Board of Directors, the case merits special consideration.
|
|
| Duplicate certificates |
$5 |
| Transfer of ownership |
$5 |
| Transfer from non-members |
$10 |
Code of Ethics
Our bylaws do not specifically provide for removal of a member
or other punitive actions due to inappropriate behavior. Rather
than try to identify specific instances and corrections, the Board
felt that issues should be considered on an individual basis.
Directors agreed that they would review any
issue regarding unethical behavior that is brought to the attention
of the Board by an active member. It was felt that since the membership
elects the Board to be their representative; the Board should have
the authority to consider these matters and to take any action that
it feels is appropriate without having to bring the matter before
the entire membership.
David Moran said that ethical behavior is very important to the
Association and Board action should be timely and decisive. Martin
stated that the Board is the steward of the integrity of the Wensleydale
breed.
Membership renewal
date
Clarification is needed in the way the bylaws explain termination
of membership, stating that membership shall terminate on March
31st of each year (corresponding to our fiscal year) and that there
is a 60-day grace period to allow members to send in their dues
without penalty. This was clarified to mean that the 60 day grace
period is for renewing without penalty, not that membership actually
extended for a total of 14 months. David Moran mentioned, and the
board agreed that listings should be removed from the member roster
on the website when membership expires - March 31st. It was clarified
that the secretary does send out renewal notices via U.S. mail.
Registration Data
Required
This item was included to record the data that we require
for registry information. The current Foundation ewe and Percentage
Blood recording forms include all of this information. In the future,
we may elect not to require as much data, but it is important that
at the inception of the registry we accumulate as many statistics
as we can.
Current info collected:
Breeders name, address, phone, FAX, email
Breeders NAWSA flock number & scrapie program number
Farm name & private ID number of the animal to be registered
(not animal nickname)
Percent of Wensleydale blood of animal to be registered
Date of birth, sex, birth type, scrapie ID number, color (white
or black), Codon 171 (required for rams only)
Is animal product of AI, OT or natural breeding, AI tech name, and
location of procedure
Sire ID, NAWSA number, % of Wensleydale blood
Dam ID, NAWSA number, % of Wensleydale blood
Pedigree of animal to be registered (if appropriate)
Request for Reconsideration
of Percentage status
Some of the original ewes that Myrtle Dow used for AI are
unregistered, but apparently purebred Cotswolds. At the first NAWSA
meeting, it was agreed that any unregistered ewes from either Myrtle
Dow or Barbara Burrows already used in the AI program would be accepted,
but would require an extra generation to qualify for registration.
This means that their daughters would become foundation ewes and
the percentage-recording paperwork would begin with them. This rule
was made because we knew that a few ewes of mixed or non-longwool
breeds had been AId with Wensleydale and we voted to accept
them with this caveat.
Upon examination and research of the pedigrees
submitted by Myrtle Dow, her original ewes appear to be purebred
Cotswold as a result of 4 and 5 generations of registered Cotwsold
sires being used. Myrtle Dow bred these (four) Cotswold ewes to
Wensleydale well before our association was formed and the guidelines
established. Myrtle has asked that we reconsider these particular
Cotswolds and recognize them as foundation ewes. Andrea Szabo made
a motion to grant Myrtles request, and to make the policy
position of the board that no other exceptions will be made. Barbara
Burrows seconded the motion, which passed unanimously. The secretary
will work with Myrtle to correct the NAWSA records on these ewes
and on the 10 lambs born from these ewes.
Location of next
Membership Meeting
At the direction of members at the last membership meeting,
Sherry Carlson made a motion to hold the next Membership Meeting
at the fiber festival in Rhinebeck NY in October 2002. Myrtle Dow
seconded and the motion passed unanimously.
Redefine "Active"
Membership
The bylaws state that "active" members are those
who own, breed or are actively involved in the promotion or development
of Wensleydale sheep. This broad definition was established in order
to include as many people as possible during the formation of the
Association. Many active members did not own or breed Wensleydale
sheep, but had expertise and background valuable to our direction.
As the membership increases, more members are actively breeding
for Wensleydales. All active members are eligible to serve as Directors,
and the Board felt that those not breeding & registering sheep
should not be charged with representing these members. Therefore,
the Board proposes to bring a change before the membership to define
an Active member as one who "Owns, breeds, and registers Wensleydale
sheep in the Association flock book each year. If no animals are
registered by an active member for a period of two consecutive years,
the member shall automatically become an Associate member".
Clarify RR Rule
for NAWSA rams
Based on the fact that the Wensleydale breed in the U.K.
is reported to test 92%RR at Codon 171, at our first membership
meeting, it was felt that this attribute be perpetuated in the North
American Wensleydale. At a time when other breed associations are
struggling to develop a more scrapie-resistant population, members
felt that the NAWSA has the opportunity to establish our breed from
the onset with highly resistant individuals, based on current industry
information. As a result, our upgrading guidelines designated that
all rams recognized in the NAWSA registry, whether imported as semen
or naturally bred, must test RR at Codon 171.
Barbara Burrows mentioned that one ram, Upper
Mill Cracker, a U.K. ram already collected and used, tests QR at
Codon 171 and that his offspring will have a higher incident of
Qs than the other rams. As a result, she believes that exceptions
should be made for rams in the Cracker line and that they should
be admitted to NAWSA records if they test QR.
Martin explained that by crossing a (worst
case scenario) QQ foundation ewe with Cracker (QR), there will still
be RR rams out of his original line that would be eligible. In this
F1 cross, statistically 1/2 of the progeny would test QQ, the other
1/2 testing QR. The next generation (75% blood) using an RR ram,
individuals would test 3/4 QR and 1/4 RR. The following generation
would produce 1/2 QR and 1/2 RR, and the 93% or registered ram generation
would produce 3/4 RR and 1/4 QR.
We realize there will be rams ineligible
for registration, but for the integrity of the national flock and
until all of the facts are known about scrapie, carrier status,
resistance and its link to genetics, we cant afford to be
wrong at this point in time.
Sherry Carlson made a motion that the restriction
of only recognizing RR rams within the registry be maintained. Martin
commented that you can always relax the standards but you cant
make them more rigid. The motion was seconded by David Moran and
a vote was taken: In favor of keeping the current guidelines - Martin
Dally, Andrea Szabo, David Moran, Sherry Carlson. Opposed to the
current guidelines - Barbara Burrows, Myrtle Dow. The motion carried
4-2.
Response to Leicester
Longwool Breeders
The secretary presented a letter of response to the Leicester
Longwool Sheep Breeders Association explaining why we cannot comply
with their request to remove Leicesters from our list of acceptable
foundation ewes. The board had no changes to the letter and instructed
the secretary to send it out.
Promotion/Advertising
Based on advertising rates and funds available for advertising,,
the board suggested that we simply keep an ongoing association listing
in The Black Sheep Newsletter, The Marker, and The Shepherd magazine.
The heading of Wensleydale will be notable in the magazine and our
association website and information will be accessible.
David Moran recommended that the association
start to organize a flock book from the onset of upgrading if our
major objectives are to be recognized by the U.K. breeders. David
and Martin will each send the secretary examples of other flock
books.
As there was no further business, the meeting
was adjourned at 9:30 pm Pacific.
Minutes submitted by Sherry Carlson
<-- return to minutes
|